Reader (voice) (3 episodes)

Martin Corrado

(6 episodes)

Lenny Savage

Hollis Nye (11 episodes)

Priest

Mr. O'Brian

Davis Langley (1 episode)

Joseph P. Terhune (5 episodes)

Professor Jergensen

Franklin Winthrop (1 episode)

(1 episode)

Zeus (voice) (2 episodes)

Other Voices (voice) (2 episodes)

Otis

Dr. Ed Walden

Uncle Chicky

Alan Stevens (2 episodes)

Walter Wade Senior

Dominic DeAngelo (1 episode)

Dominic DeAngelo

Emily's Father

Steve Maggadino Sr.

Randall Winston, Sr. (archive footage) (2 episodes)

Malvolio

Colonel John O. Bailey

Professor Clark

Benjamin Franklin (6 episodes)

Dr. Hofstader

Palermo Racine (1 episode)

Walter Wallace

Mike Killabrew (1 episode)

Uncle Carmine Morelli

Vincenzo

Patsy

Judge Flatt

Chief Wycoff

Mort

(voice) (4 episodes)

Jerry the Pope

Chief

Oswald

Frank Scacciapensieri

(7 episodes)

Gene Perlman

Mr. Paulsen

Art Malto

Lt. Ray Silak, NYPD

Sen. Frank Steubens

Narrator (voice) (1 episode)

Defense Attorney Gordon Schell (3 episodes)

Dobbs (1 episode)

Lee Jerrold (1 episode)

Horace Greeley (9 episodes)

Bus Driver

Self - Narrator (voice) (1 episode)

Frank Turner

Wycoff

O'Malley

Sam Posner

Oren Trask

John Wycoff

Sam

Det. Sgt. Melkowitz

Judge Garb (2 episodes)

Judge Garb

Dawson (1 episode)

Paul Gray

Grandfather

Thomas Colfax (2 episodes)

Thomas Colfax

Dr. Curtis Franklin

Boss William Tweed

Brian (1 episode)

Oscar (1 episode)

Curly

James Flanagan

Brother Paul

Paulie's Father

Doctor

Dr. Harry Wallenberg (1 episode)

Father Coyne (1 episode)

Father Coyne

Fuller

(1 episode)