McGivney (4 episodes)

Gin Blake

Nicky (5 episodes)

Bertram B. Beveridge

Joseph Scalvo

Cesar Caputo (1 episode)

Wendell Kirk (4 episodes)

Mayo

Detective Erickson

Dr. Gabe Krasner (2 episodes)

Jerry (2 episodes)

Wes Buchwalter (1 episode)

Jack Paulson (1 episode)

Honey

Bob Sowoski (1 episode)

Horace Powell

Monroe (1 episode)

Sheriff

Ferry Captain

Mudgett (1 episode)

Kenneth 'Lou' Shea (93 episodes)

Story (1 episode)

Transit Cop (1 episode)

Stan Sher

John (1 episode)

Pizza Boy

Fred DeLuca (1 episode)

Chunky Gay Guy (1 episode)

(1 episode)

Reporter (4 episodes)

Lodge Owner (1 episode)

Ticket Agent

Jansen (1 episode)

Hoeck (1 episode)

Bruno Scagnetti (1 episode)

Anton Vittelli (1 episode)

Guard #2

Lt. Steve Milford

John Boothby