Charlie

Sam Stackhouse

Self - Guest (1 episode)

Self (1 episode)

Sam Stackhouse

Self - Host (76 episodes)

Self - Contestant (1 episode)

Detective Mike Kingston

Detective Mike Kingston

Dylan

Self - Guest (1 episode)

Scott Morris

Detective Mike Kingston

Edward

(1 episode)

Professor Noah Ferris

Self - Host (3 episodes)

Will

Henry

Tim

Detective Mike Kingston

Supervising Producer

John Blake

Self - Host (6 episodes)

Detective Mike Kingston

Self (29 episodes)

Detective Mike Kingston

Self

Detective Mike Kingston

Detective Mike Kingston

Rob (1 episode)

Self (2 episodes)

Carter

Mike Logan

Henry Parker

Kenneth

Tim Pierce

Josh Camden

Bill (1 episode)

Jacob Kelly

Bryant Meyers

Vince Powers (1 episode)

Self - Contestant (16 episodes)

Self - Audience Member (1 episode)

Self (2 episodes)

Self (1 episode)

Self (2 episodes)

(32 episodes)

Dillon Smith (3 episodes)

Gary Babcock

Noah (1 episode)

Stanley Mitchell (1 episode)

Danny Pasqualle (1 episode)

Kirk (1 episode)

(1 episode)

(1 episode)

Atlanta

Mike Murphy

Masked Man (1 episode)

Rich Eastman

Ryan Lavery (2338 episodes)