(1 episode)

Adam

Oscar

Sam Davies

Milton Hershey

Movie Director

Tom Bell

Richard

Glenn Martin (1 episode)

August Landmesser

Coach Laidlaw

Luke Harrison

Tony Cameron

Ethan Davis

Bart

Himself

Edmund Tolleson (8 episodes)

Jaeger

Mickey Deans

Self - Guest (1 episode)

Kyle

Steve

Clayton

Hayward

Seth

Executive Producer

Jonny Collins

Jeffrey Trail (4 episodes)

Tim Matheson

Nate

Demetrius

Greg Earnest

Spencer Koll

Writer

Jamie Shipley

Freddie Steinmark

Francis 'Mac' McNamara

Dandy Mott (13 episodes)

Harry Gardner (5 episodes)

Jether Polk (archive footage) (1 episode)

Jether Polk (2 episodes)

Rudolph Valentino (3 episodes)

Tristan Duffy (6 episodes)

Bobby Richter (1 episode)

Albert

Young Tubal-cain

Gabriel

Cameron Tyler (1 episode)

Dale (4 episodes)

Jimmy Cormack (1 episode)

Harvey Morell (1 episode)

Danny (1 episode)

Warren

Chad Van Horn (1 episode)

Cody

Thomas Yoder (1 episode)

Young Eric (1 episode)