Anton Johnston (1 episode)

Logan Wendig (1 episode)

Officer Ribisi (1 episode)

Frank Sadler (1 episode)

Jake (1 episode)

Stewart Pringle/Wilson Kubiak (1 episode)

Dad

Gary Sharp (1 episode)

Anthony Onofrio (13 episodes)

Cameron Miller (8 episodes)

FBI Agent (22 episodes)

Paulie / Goldberg

Officer Randy Cutter (1 episode)

Alex Lipton (2 episodes)

Justin Ogilvie (1 episode)

Paul Denby (4 episodes)

Lt. Matt Ventura (1 episode)

Joel Mitchell (16 episodes)

Cop #2 (Quint)

Shane Rinaldi (1 episode)

Boyfriend (1 episode)

Nick Valentino (22 episodes)

Michael (1 episode)

Bruce Theobald (1 episode)