Spudvisor
Holmes

Kelly Mallet (27 episodes)

Sam Straley

Lloyd 'Shrub' Mallet (27 episodes)

Seann William Scott

Joseph 'Father Joe' Binghoffer (27 episodes)

Justin Linville
Krystal Smith

Mandy 'Big Mandy' Matthews (27 episodes)

Aya Cash

Cheryl Peterson (27 episodes)

Taylor Ortega

Nadine Garcia-Parney (27 episodes)

Ed Wagenseller

Sheriff's Deputy (2 episodes)

Josh Warren

Robot Scarecrow (1 episode)

Gabriella Cila
Lee Armstrong

S. Perkins / D. Perkins (1 episode)

Ginny MacColl

Kelly's Grandma (1 episode)

Martina Litty

Nadine's Friend (1 episode)

Chad Michael Baird

Flatch Town Local (1 episode)

Craig Newkirk
Kent West

Townsperson #2 (1 episode)

Jana Allen

Parishioner (1 episode)

Rakesh Gosain

Maintenance Man (1 episode)

Gabe Wood

Townsperson #1 (1 episode)

Stella Threatt

Baby Ashlynn #1 (1 episode)

Ellie Threatt

Baby Ashlynn #2 (1 episode)

Ron Blake

Featured Parade Bass Drummer (uncredited) (1 episode)

Shane Burnett

Flatchian (uncredited) (1 episode)

Logan Newkirk

Featured Parade Member (uncredited) (1 episode)

Andrew Brooks

Ice Cream Man (uncredited) (1 episode)

William G. Tomek

Pedestrian (uncredited) (1 episode)

Rebekah Kostyal

Laughing Woman #1 (1 episode)

Mennelly

Laughing Woman #2 (1 episode)

Keeley Kollmann

Realtor (uncredited) (1 episode)

Mitch Eakins

Rick "The Hot Hermit" (1 episode)

Heather Magee

Ohio Influencer (1 episode)

Stephen Branson

Flatchian (uncredited) (1 episode)

Whit Blanchard

Lloyd Mallet Esq. (1 episode)

Nathan Penrose

Toy Drive Attendee (uncredited) (1 episode)

Jenny Bicks

Executive Producer (27 episodes)

Charlie Cooper

Original Series Creator (27 episodes)

Daisy May Cooper

Original Series Creator (27 episodes)

Angie Stephenson

Executive Producer (27 episodes)

Dan Magnante

Co-Executive Producer (14 episodes)

Cathy Mason

Co-Executive Producer (14 episodes)

Greg Lubin

Associate Producer (2 episodes)

Emma Strain

Consulting Producer (2 episodes)

Callie Miller

Associate Producer (1 episode)