Executive Producer (6 episodes)

Joel Schwartz (6 episodes)

Leah Askey (6 episodes)

Mariah Day (6 episodes)

Mark Hupp (6 episodes)

Janet (6 episodes)

Detective Ryan McCarrick (6 episodes)

Betsy Faria (6 episodes)

Russ Faria (6 episodes)

Narrator (voice) (6 episodes)

Lily Day (6 episodes)

Nate Swanson (5 episodes)

Travis Hupp (5 episodes)

Tina (5 episodes)

Detective Merkel (4 episodes)

Cousin Mary (4 episodes)

Tammy (4 episodes)

Sarah Hupp (3 episodes)

Sarah Hupp (uncredited) (1 episode)

Luci (4 episodes)

Cathy Singer (4 episodes)

Channel 2 Reporter (4 episodes)

Minnie (4 episodes)

Mike Wood (3 episodes)

Juror #2 (3 episodes)

Captain Mike Lang (3 episodes)

Bonnie (3 episodes)

Louis Gumpenberger (2 episodes)

Jerry (2 episodes)

Gus (2 episodes)

Judge Mennemeyer (2 episodes)

Sean Walker (2 episodes)

Jim (2 episodes)

Evan (2 episodes)

Firefighter (2 episodes)

Whitney (2 episodes)

Sarah at 11 Years Old (1 episode)

Young Sarah (1 episode)

Michael J. Kruse (2 episodes)

Bailiff (2 episodes)

Scott (2 episodes)

Young Mark Hupp (2 episodes)

Lisa (2 episodes)

Shirley Neumann (2 episodes)

Friendly Nurse (2 episodes)

News Reporter (2 episodes)

Leah Askey's Daughter (2 episodes)

Greg Chatton (2 episodes)

Officer Divozzo (1 episode)

CSI Tech (1 episode)

Officer Rose (1 episode)

O'Fallon Office Dave (1 episode)

Darla (1 episode)

Polygrapher (1 episode)

Plastic Surgeon (1 episode)

Courtroom Bailiff (1 episode)

Juror #3 (1 episode)

Russ' Family Member (1 episode)

Teenage Witch (1 episode)

Sarah at 6 Years Old (1 episode)

Randy Gunderson (1 episode)

Young Pam Hupp (1 episode)

News Photographer (uncredited) (1 episode)

Zumba Instructor (1 episode)

Bob Rivers (1 episode)

Big Shot Manager (1 episode)

Attorney (uncredited) (1 episode)

Reporter #1 (1 episode)

Btian Hilke (1 episode)

Officer Carrigan (1 episode)

Inmate (1 episode)

Judge Ted House (1 episode)

Prisoner (1 episode)

Judge Cunningham (1 episode)

O'Fallon County Operator (1 episode)

Bradford Kessler (1 episode)

911 Operator (1 episode)

CSI Tech (1 episode)

Bar Patron (uncredited) (1 episode)

Judge Ohmer (1 episode)

Bubbly Acolyte (1 episode)

Auctioneer #1 (1 episode)

Cybercrimes Expert (1 episode)

Teen Pet Shop Employee (1 episode)

Realtor Sally (1 episode)

Carol Alford (1 episode)

Louis' Mom (1 episode)

PV Fake Louis (1 episode)

Courtroom - family friend (uncredited) (1 episode)

Costume Design (6 episodes)

Director (2 episodes)

Executive Producer (6 episodes)

Director (2 episodes)

Producer (1 episode)

Line Producer (6 episodes)

Associate Producer (6 episodes)

Executive Producer (6 episodes)

Associate Producer (6 episodes)

Executive Producer (6 episodes)

Writer (2 episodes)

Teleplay (1 episode)

Executive Producer (6 episodes)

Teleplay (1 episode)

Co-Producer (6 episodes)

Executive Producer (6 episodes)

Executive Producer (6 episodes)

Executive Producer (6 episodes)

Executive Producer (6 episodes)

Teleplay (1 episode)

Producer (2 episodes)

Original Music Composer (6 episodes)

Original Music Composer (6 episodes)

Writer (1 episode)

Staff Writer (5 episodes)

Writer (1 episode)

Teleplay (1 episode)

Teleplay (1 episode)